Dieon Sanders dominated the NFL but couldn't bat his weight in baseball.
Michael Jordan couldn’t sniff minor league baseball either.
Ricky Willimas a horrible pro baseball player too.
I don’t know about Ricky Williams, b/c up until you mentioned him I never knew he even tried baseball. What you mentioned were two guys that couldn’t hit the ball, sorry but in my opinion, that’s not athleticism. It is timing, focus, hand eye coordination, and bat speed. Having a 40" vert or being able to run a 4.2 40 is not going to help you at the plate. Good try though.
I’m not saying baseball players are not athletes and I will agree that a good MLB CF is a high level athlete, on par with many other sports. I’m just saying if you take a summation of athletic ability from every position they’re not equivalent to other sports.
[B]MLS does not require more athletic ability than MLB.[/B] Hockey is a tough call, but NFL some spots require more and some require less. NBA is definitely the most athletic sport.
Remember, Deion Sanders, Bo Jackson, Michael Jordan, etc. played baseball, not Fabio or Renaldo or Beckham.
I would say MLB CF is about just as athletic, if not more athletic than any other pro athlete.
I hope you’ve played soccer at a decent level and not on a rec league team. I played against guys who eventually went on to play at Wake, Chapel Hill, and UVA (not slouches at the collegiate level). These guys could easily run 40 times on par with NFL players, had verticals very similar to NBA players and are required to have the stamina that outlasts any other sport. MLS may have been a bad comparison since outside of a few players is essentially a minor league compared to the top leagues in Europe.
Fabio, Renaldo, Beckham? Soccer is the dominate sport in their countries, so yea I don’t expect them to play baseball. Deion was also a standout in track and field at the collegiate level as well, and I want to say Bo was too, but I can’t say for sure.
As you somewhat eluded to with your NFL comment, certain sports require certain athletic abilities and among positions in those sports some require more athletic ability. I just feel baseball as a whole is at the lesser end.