[QUOTE=NinerAdvocate;409913]Note - I am not a Trekkie. Just a casual fan.
Star Trek - 2.75 out of 4 stars.
Not a clunker, but unevenly cast and poorly written. Eomer is not Bones, and is trying to play DeForest Kelly instead of McCoy. Every tagline was forced into the story, and it was awkward, and the general plot was really weak, (Spoiler - Highlight following to read) [COLOR=LemonChiffon]and just an excuse to not have continuity problems with the established characters.[/COLOR]
Tension in the movie was all based on fast action scenes, and not the classic slow build tension of the original movies (which I rather missed). This iteration of crewmen are a bunch of adrenaline fueled cowboys (even Spock, comparatively), and the movie suffers, missing the feeling of the classic high seas explorers that the series was based on (and reinforced on the big screen).
Definitely didn’t hate it, but the bottom line is that the script was an exercise in trying to include as many referential line items from focus group sessions as possible, plus the aforementioned continuity exercise. There was no depth to it at all. It felt very Starship Troopers, and less classic character drama set in space.
IMHO - Abrams (sp?) needs to invest some serious effort into the plot and character development of the next script, or this is just going to be another Starship Troopers sequel with a better backstory. They may also have to pull a Batman and recast some of the actors. Karl Urban is not McCoy.
I will say that the new Scotty was refreshing, and likeable. The special effects, are, of course, amazingly polished and pure eye candy.[/QUOTE]
Interesting. You’re the first person I’ve read who didn’t like Urban’s McCoy. In fact most publications I’ve read praised his performance as the best of the whole movie. My only real issues with the movie was the Nero character was a weakly developed villian with very little dialog and a hollow and forced backstory. Also, Kirk from Cadet to Captain was one of the greatest stretches of rank structure in Star Trek history.